The Fine Art Society Ltd
Skip to main content
  • Menu
  • Artworks
  • Artists
  • Exhibitions
  • Viewing Room
  • About
  • Frames
  • Contact
Menu
  • Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886

    Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW 1859-1930

    Boy with a straw, 1886
    signed and dated '86
    oil on canvas
    16 ¼ x 12 inches

    Further images

    • (View a larger image of thumbnail 1 ) Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    • (View a larger image of thumbnail 2 ) Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    • (View a larger image of thumbnail 3 ) Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    • (View a larger image of thumbnail 4 ) Sir James Guthrie HRA PRSA HRSW, Boy with a straw, 1886
    For James Guthrie, the summer months of 1882 were crucial. Depictions of steep, grassy hillsides with resting labourers, painted in the open-air, in emulation of Jules Bastien Lepage’s Les Foins,...
    Read more
    For James Guthrie, the summer months of 1882 were crucial. Depictions of steep, grassy hillsides with resting labourers, painted in the open-air, in emulation of Jules Bastien Lepage’s Les Foins, (Musée d’Orsay, Paris) became a favourite motif. However, as his work developed throughout the mid-1880s, Guthrie faced insurmountable difficulties that at one point led him to think of abandoning his career as a painter. The astonishing succès d’estime of his early work could not be sustained and even medium-sized canvases such as Schoolmates (Musée des Beaux Arts, Ghent) took much longer to complete than anticipated, while large works such as Fieldworkers sheltering from a Shower and The Stonebreaker were either delayed, destroyed or dismembered.

    We look therefore to the few extant smaller works of these crucial years to gain access to Guthrie’s thinking. They reveal a formidable talent at moments when not under strain. Boy with a Straw, dated 1886, comes from this sequence. Guthrie’s brushwork is sketchy, spontaneous and expressive. The trees may be moving in a light breeze; the haystack and foreground debris are swiftly noted, but the artist sees no reason to sharpen contours or finish forms. This boy might be posing yet, having pulled a piece of straw from the haystack, he now engages both artist and spectator. Guthrie’s important little canvas coincides with Walton’s A Daydream (1885, National Galleries Scotland) and may even have suggested what became its essential mise-en-scène.

    The relationship is obvious: Guthrie’s boy, like Walton’s girl, sits facing the spectator with his legs splayed out, and boots upturned. Yet where Walton perfects his picture for exhibition, Guthrie retains that sense of the temporary unfinished encounter. But in that moment of calm in the summer of 1886, when a boy with a straw in his hand marches up a hillside and sits before him, Guthrie’s realisation was complete – and for Glasgow School painters there was now a new visual turn.
    Close full details

    Provenance

    gifted to William G. Gardiner, the artist’s uncle and patron; thence by descent to his great nephew Dr Neil Guthrie, his son Ian Guthrie, to his first cousin
    Enquire
    %3Cdiv%20class%3D%22artist%22%3ESir%20James%20Guthrie%20HRA%20PRSA%20HRSW%3C/div%3E%3Cdiv%20class%3D%22title_and_year%22%3E%3Cspan%20class%3D%22title_and_year_title%22%3EBoy%20with%20a%20straw%3C/span%3E%2C%20%3Cspan%20class%3D%22title_and_year_year%22%3E1886%3C/span%3E%3C/div%3E%3Cdiv%20class%3D%22signed_and_dated%22%3Esigned%20and%20dated%20%2786%3C/div%3E%3Cdiv%20class%3D%22medium%22%3Eoil%20on%20canvas%3C/div%3E%3Cdiv%20class%3D%22dimensions%22%3E16%20%C2%BC%20x%2012%20inches%3C/div%3E

  

EDINBURGH

6 Dundas Street

Edinburgh EH3 6HZ

+44(0) 131 557 4050  

edinburgh@thefineartsociety.com

Open Mon to Fri 10am - 6pm, Sat 11am - 2pm

LONDON 

Marlborough Court, 25 Carnaby Street

London W1F 7DE 

+44(0) 20 7629 5116

london@thefineartsociety.com

Open Mon to Fri 10am - 6pm

Please make an appointment as, from time to time, the gallery is unmanned. 

Facebook, opens in a new tab.
Twitter, opens in a new tab.
Instagram, opens in a new tab.
Join the mailing list
Send an email
Legal
Manage cookies
Copyright © 2023 The Fine Art Society Ltd
Site by Artlogic

The Fine Art Society uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more.

Manage cookies
Accept

Cookie preferences

Check the boxes for the cookie categories you allow our site to use

Cookie options
Required for the website to function and cannot be disabled.
Improve your experience on the website by storing choices you make about how it should function.
Allow us to collect anonymous usage data in order to improve the experience on our website.
Allow us to identify our visitors so that we can offer personalised, targeted marketing.
Save preferences
Close

Join our mailing list

Interests *

Categories *

Signup

* denotes required fields

We will process the personal data you have supplied to communicate with you in accordance with our Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe or change your preferences at any time by clicking the link in our emails.